Movie Reviews

Movie Review: Grace Pudl Must Get Her Head Out Of Her Shell To Gain Confidence And Move Forward In “Memoir Of A Snail”

A bittersweet memoir of a melancholic woman called Grace Pudel – a hoarder of snails, romance novels, and guinea pigs.

The night I attended this press screening, the film was preceded by an interview with Adam Elliot, the writer and director, and Jackie Weaver, the voice actress who gives life to Pinky, a pivotal character. In that interview, Elliot made much of his use of stop motion animation and the story woven within that animation. He explained his choice to eliminate color from the film, pulling only from a brown palette to present the deep melancholy of the storyline. The storyline was loosely based on his life, typical of his filmmaking and storywriting approach.

If you are unfamiliar with stop-motion animation, you have undoubtedly seen it used in simple cartoons like “Mr. Bill” and “Gumby.” However, “Memoir of a Snail” is a stop-motion animation that has been raised to quite an elevated level. There is art to this “Claymation,” as Elliot calls it. The first scene is filled to overflowing with the tiniest details to set the scene for what follows and Elliot’s directorial expertise rises to the fore. Grace Pudl (Sarah Snook) and her twin brother, Gilbert (Kodi Smit-McPhee), are tragic siblings who lose their parents early on and are split up and placed in separated homes by possibly well-meaning but overworked social workers who give no thought to keeping twins together. At that point, the story of Grace begins to meander through her trials and travails as her foster parents, a hilarious couple of swingers/nudists, eventually leave her and retire at a nudist camp. Nude clay characters left me pondering the animator charged with producing them. That would be an interesting time at work.

The sad, introverted Grace is absorbed by snails and keeps a collection of everything “snail”: ceramic pieces, pictures, figurines, and even live snails she keeps in a jar. The snail itself mirrors Grace’s lonely, solitary life, with each day slowly moving forward at, dare I say, a “snail’s pace.”

Grace is taken under the wing of the quite elderly but quirky Pinky (Jacki Weaver), who cares for her uniquely and is Grace’s saving grace. The film’s storyline meanders and, I suppose, mirrors a snail’s winding, circular shell. Those whorls on that shell go nowhere, and I thought that’s where this film story might end up, though it finally reaches a roundabout conclusion. Thanks once again, Pinky.

Elliot is undoubtedly a brilliant stop-motion animator who pays total attention to the tiniest detail; his resume certainly speaks to that. However, his story writing is not at the same level of quality. I found it a bit immature and catering to the animation rather than the quite effective animation supporting a story that rose to the same level. I will be back for his next film, however, as it’s an art form to be appreciated and enjoyed, and obviously one Elliot is obsessed with.

In Theaters Friday, November 8th

 

 

3.4k
20k
Pinterest1.5k
Linked In1.3k

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Mildred Austin

I can remember being a girl fascinated by the original CINDERELLA and trying to understand that the characters weren’t REAL?? But how was that possible? Because my mom was a cinema lover, she often took me with her instead of leaving me with a babysitter. I was so young in my first film experiences, I would stare at that BIG screen and wonder “what were those people up there saying?” And then as a slightly older girl watching Margaret O’Brien in THE RED SHOES, I dreamed of being a ballerina. Later, in a theatre with my mom and aunt watching WUTHERING HEIGHTS, I found myself sobbing along with the two of them as Katherine and Heathcliff were separated forever. I have always loved film. In college in the ’60s, the Granada in Dallas became our “go-to” art theater where we soaked up 8 ½, THROUGH A GLASS DARKLY, WILD STRAWBERRIES and every other Bergman film to play there. Although my training is in theatre and I have acted and directed in Repertory Theatre, college and community theatre, I am always drawn back to the films.

I live in Garland and after being retired for 18 years, I have gone back to work in an elementary school library. I am currently serving as an Associate Critic for John Garcia’s THE COLUMN, an online theatre magazine and I see and review local community theatre shows for that outlet. I’m excited to have the opportunity to extend my experiences now to film and review for IRISH FILM CRITIC. See you at the movies - my preferred seat is back row!