Two friends navigate the dangerous world of organized crime, testing their loyalty and survival skills as they get deeper into the criminal underworld.
“Mike & Nick & Nick & Alice” arrived on my radar with almost no warning. I hadn’t caught any trailers, seen any posters, or read a single promotional blurb ahead of its March 27th release. In hindsight, I’m glad I went in blind, as the film was a pleasant surprise.
In this crime dramedy from writer-director BenDavid Grabinski, a formidable cast—Vince Vaughn, James Marsden, Eiza González, and Keith David—brings to life a story set deep within the criminal underworld. We meet Mike (Marsden), Nick (Vaughn), Alice (González), and, unexpectedly, another Nick (also Vaughn).
Mike and Nick share a long friendship, but Mike is ready to leave their violent past behind. He’s tired of the bloodshed and dreams of starting over, this time with Alice—who, complicating matters, is Nick’s wife. Mike and Alice plan a secret meeting at a quiet hotel, but when Mike arrives, it’s not Alice who shows up—it’s Nick. Sensing that Nick suspects the affair, Mike is drawn into one last job at Nick’s insistence.
Trying to keep the peace, Mike agrees. At Nick’s house, Mike is handed a cloth and a bottle of chloroform, with instructions to knock out whoever answers the door. Mike complies, only to find Nick himself answering. A struggle ensues; Nick escapes, leaving Mike in confusion.
Things take a sharp turn when the other Nick returns, explaining that he is actually from six months in the future. Mike, understandably skeptical, is soon convinced when Future Nick reveals knowledge about Mike’s relationship with Alice. They track down Present Nick and bring Alice into the fold. She is unfazed by the existence of two Nicks and reveals that her friend Symon (Ben Schwartz), a self-described nerdy scientist, had been working on a time machine—which, clearly, succeeded. Future Nick recounts that he found Symon’s machine, traveled back in time to this night, and in the chaos that followed, Symon was killed and the machine destroyed.
Future Nick then reveals a darker twist: Present Nick, upon discovering Mike’s relationship with Alice, told their boss Sosa (Keith David) that Mike had betrayed Sosa’s son, Jimmy Boy (Jimmy Tatro), to the police. Jimmy Boy ended up in prison, and Sosa is now out for revenge, with a notorious assassin hired to track Mike down.
Racked with regret for setting these events in motion, Future Nick wants to prevent Mike’s death and spare himself the burden of guilt. He tries to persuade Present Nick not to repeat his mistakes. With the time machine destroyed, the group has only one chance to put things right, and the stakes could not be higher.
Grabinski deserves credit for subverting the usual time travel formula. Unlike films such as “Groundhog Day” or “Edge of Tomorrow,” where characters can keep resetting until they get it right, there are no do-overs here. This single-shot approach ratchets up the tension and keeps the narrative taut.
The film balances suspense with comedy, offering several genuinely funny moments. Marsden, González, and David deliver strong performances, but it’s Vince Vaughn who stands out. Portraying two versions of Nick, Vaughn gives Future Nick a depth and maturity that grounds the film emotionally. His portrayal of a man haunted by guilt and desperate to make amends is both moving and authentic. Vaughn’s quieter, introspective scenes elevate the film, distinguishing it from more disposable action comedies.
“Mike & Nick & Nick & Alice” is a rare blend of excitement, humor, and genuine drama. It’s a film that manages to satisfy fans of all three genres, and it marks a welcome return to form for Vince Vaughn.
Premieres exclusively on Hulu Friday, March 27th
10k
21.1k
1.5k
2.2k